I think she was rolling her eyes at Abby not Maddie.
My reaction to Teen Wolf, season 4, episode 8, “Time of Death”:
malia and stiles in bed (i just realized she ran her fingers thru his hair)
OMG HE WAS DREAMING ABOUT HER
"it’s like you guys know something i don’t."
so to my understanding scott is suppose to seem like he is dead to…